With rare exceptions, no one likes being called a Luddite. Steve Talbott, the thoughtful, somewhat skeptical philosopher who writes the Netfuture e-mail newsletter, for example, takes offense at being labeled “pessimistic.” I thought it was a fair beef, but he devoted considerable space in his last missive to a defense of his position and denied that he was negative

It’s easy to be a critic: Technology may not be a poisoned chalice, but it sure is a Mickey Finn. Focusing on the flaws is a simple way to stake out a position, and one that can be especially gratifying when the other half of humanity is touting the wonders of our digital future.

The real problem is that the middle ground isn’t sexy. Pragmatism is so boring. “On the one hand … on the other hand…” Balance, objectivity — fine stuff, but real snoozers.

Take the “technorealists.” Please.

They debuted last year with a manifesto that declared “technology is making life more convenient and enjoyable, and many of us healthier, wealthier and wiser. But it is also affecting work, family and the economy in unpredictable ways, introducing new forms of tension and distraction and posing new threats to the cohesion of our physical communities. … We see profound benefits as well as substantial costs. We anticipate mixed blessings from today’s emerging technologies …”

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW