Environment Feb 11, 2007

Vitriol vies with science

by David Mcneill

For journalists used to the smooth diplomatic hum of the global conference circuit, covering the poisonous annual meetings of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) is akin to being slapped in the face with a slab of week-old minke bacon. Government representatives from across the ...

The price of stalemate

Environment Feb 11, 2007

The price of stalemate

by David Mcneill

One of the most controversial elements of Japan's campaign to overturn the International Whaling Commission's 1986 commercial whaling ban is the alleged use of official Overseas Development Aid to "buy" the votes of poorer IWC member-countries. That is an allegation vehemently denied by fisheries ...

Environment Feb 11, 2007

From the inside looking out . . .

by David Mcneill

'There are a number of factors, both biological and economic, which led the industry to destroy one whale species after another, even though the industry was dependent on their survival. Thus, the commercial whaling ban should be kept and not mixed up with the ...

Japan and the whaling ban

Environment Feb 11, 2007

Japan and the whaling ban

It is a question that puzzles much of the world: Why does Japan thumb its nose at one of the environmental movement's few lasting achievements -- the International Whaling Commission's 1986 ban on commercial whaling? With Japan's whaling fleet again in Antarctic waters hunting minke ...

Siege mentality fuels 'sustainability' claims

Environment Feb 11, 2007

Siege mentality fuels 'sustainability' claims

by David Mcneill

At the government's Fisheries Agency in Tokyo, which drives the prowhaling campaign in Japan, there is thinly disguised contempt for the antiwhaling finger-wagging of New Zealand, a country with boundless rich farmland and a tiny population to support. In contrast, Japan's food self-sufficiency is extremely ...

Environment Feb 11, 2007

Deadlock is dominant in whaling's 'petty parlor game'

by David Mcneill

In light of the entrenched positions involved, the whaling issue appears hopelessly deadlocked as the prowhaling nations led by Japan, Iceland and Norway demand the right to return to commercial whaling from countries equally determined to resist them. Inside Japan, the government's Fisheries Agency (FA) ...