Dear Alice,
As a longtime resident of Japan, I have watched with interest the recent installation of barriers on the platforms of many of our subway and train lines. These barriers run the full length of the platform and have sliding gates at just the places where there are train doors when a train is in the station. I presume these barriers are there to prevent passengers from falling off the platforms, but this smells to me like paternalistic overprotection. Do accidents really happen often enough to justify the expense? What the heck is the logic here?
Connor F., Tokyo

Dear Connor,
I’m not sure whether to thank you or spank you for bringing this to my attention. I travel every day through stations with unprotected platforms but hadn’t thought much about risk.

Sure, an open-style platform works fine when all systems are normal. But what if a crowd swarmed the platform? Or if a dizzy spell befell me? Or if I got a big bump from behind? All of a sudden my daily commute feels like an accident waiting to happen.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW