In November 2007, a Kyoto psychiatrist was prosecuted for leaking investigative materials to a journalist concerning a 17-year-old boy who was tried in family court in connection with a fire that killed his stepmother and two siblings. But the freelance journalist, who published a book using the leaked materials, did not face prosecution. A third-party committee established by the publisher, Kodansha Ltd., to investigate the matter, made public its report in early April.

The report says that carelessness on the part of the author and editors led to the disclosure of the news source and invited intervention by public prosecutors. Although the author, journalist Atsuko Kusanagi, has criticized the committee for using material she collected without her permission, the committee’s findings serve as a reminder that reporters and editors must live up to long-established journalistic principles and ethics to prevent erosion of the freedom of expression.

The 17-year-old boy set fire to his home in the town of Tawaramoto, Nara Prefecture, on June 20, 2006. The bodies of the boy’s 38-year-old stepmother, 7-year-old half brother and 5-year-old half sister, were found in the debris. The boy, then in his first year of high school, was arrested in Kyoto two days later. After he confessed to setting the fire, the Nara District Public Prosecutors Office sent him to the Nara Family Court in July 2006, which ordered psychiatric testing. That October, a psychiatric test report that Dr. Morimitsu Sakihama submitted to the court concluded that the boy suffered from an attention-deficit disorder.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW