• Matsumoto, Nagano

While
I sympathize with the editorial goals of Yoshi Tsurumi in his Aug. 28 article, “McCain aims to win by pandering to bigotry” — about U.S. Sen. John McCain’s attacks on Sen. Barack Obama — I feel that Tsurumi crosses the line from legitimate complaint and analysis into hysterical and inaccurate lamenting.

Some of the things that Tsurumi claims just don’t make sense — for example, that “Anti-Semitic whispering among Southern white Christians spread the vicious lie that Obama is an anti-Christ Muslim.” While there have been plenty of ludicrous claims about Obama’s religion, such claims cannot, by definition, be “anti-Semitic.” An anti-Semite by the commonly accepted definition used today is someone who is bigoted against Jewish people. To link the claim that Obama is Muslim (as opposed to Christian) with anti-Semitism is fallacious.

I also dispute Tsurumi’s claim that the McCain campaign’s ad invoking the images of Britney Spears and Paris Hilton is intended to appeal to “deep-seated” prejudices among white males. The image put forth by Spears and Hilton are those of “train-wreck” celebrities, whose antics produce little if anything of value and who seem famous only because they contribute to the paparazzi pages. The ad draws on this image; it does not play on racism or deep-seated prejudice.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW