Gregory Clark’s May 12 article, “Northern Territories dispute lives on self-righteous deadlock,” contains some inaccuracies:
First, the San Francisco Conference was held during the Truman administration, and the American in charge was Dean Atcheson, who was well-known for his anti-Japanese views.
Second, Japan’s renunciation of the Kuril Islands was not then and is not now legally binding on Japan vis-a-vis the Russian side. Under international law, a treaty is not binding on a nonparty who denounces it. The Soviet Union was not a party to the treaty and formally denounced it in 1952.

With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.