In his June 12 Counterpoint article, “Barber’s cutting comment denies others’ humanity — and hers, too,” Roger Pulvers lamented his young Korean barber’s stereotypical and dehumanizing view of the Japanese and her inability to see other cultures from any viewpoint other than her own.

While I can readily agree that the ability to feel grief — among several other basic human emotions — is undoubtedly universal among human beings, I doubt that it is the “very same grief” to the “very same degree” regardless of background or location. If that were so, then what role would culture and environment, personal history and personality possibly play?

Pulvers is right to maintain that observable cultural differences, in the way and degree of expressing grief, do not necessarily imply that one’s internal experience of grief is different. However, as unexpressed emotion is by nature invisible to others, it is also possible that it is experienced differently. Given the influence of each particular culture and unique personality, I would say that it is likely to be different.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW