Some additional information needs to be added to the Aug. 17 Japan Times editorial, “Ray of light amid the nuclear gloom.”

The editorial mentions an estimated 23.5 gigawatts of geothermal potential in Japan. This figure is cited in the scientific paper “2010 Country Update for Japan,” by H. Sugino and T. Akeno, presented at the 2010 World Geothermal Congress. In their paper, they identify many problems with accessing this geothermal potential, including lack of techniques for fully identifying the geothermal structure in the exploration phase; the time and investment needed to bring a geothermal development to fruition; and the fact that the easiest areas for geothermal power development have already been developed. They say a technical breakthrough to develop unused geothermal potential is necessary. So accessing that 23.5 GW is in no way assured.

On the solar power front, Tokyo Electric Power Co. has a new solar plant in Kawasaki, with an area of around 0.8 square kilometer. Its output is around 20 megawatts. To get the 150,000 MW Environment Ministry figure given in the editorial, we would need 7,500 more of these plants — covering an area of 6,000 sq. km. But since solar power plants have irregular output (the Tepco solar plant average output is around 12 percent of the maximum rating), the area needed to get the Environment Ministry number is closer to 50,000 sq. km, or slightly more than 13 percent of Japan’s surface area. Given that such plants need to be built on flat ground, and that Japan’s land is around 70 percent mountainous, we’re looking at taking up almost 45 percent of Japan’s nonmountainous land. We would need 50 billion solar panels (at 1 sq. meter each) to cover this area, and a lot of toxic waste is produced in the manufacture of solar panels.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW