As an “English gentleman,” brought up in the latter days of the British Empire, I was encouraged to feel “superior” in being British. As a military officer, I was instructed to be superior to those of a lower rank, so I know much about “superiority”. But we were taught NOT to feel superior in matters of race, creed, culture, history, etc.

I was deeply disturbed to read in Nicolas Gattig’s Nov. 22 article, “MacArthur, identity theory and Japan’s lingering eigo woes,” that 60 years after the end of the war “native speakers of English complain about the tight-lipped Japanese” and that many Western people, “even those who appreciate Japanese culture … believe themselves to be intellectually superior to their Japanese interlocutors.”

I admit that this has been and is currently a common thought among “Western” (I believe predominantly American, not European!) residents and visitors in Japan, but not everyone thinks and feels that way. As for the so-called Japanese inability to speak English, especially in language schools, that is clearly and solely the responsibility of the teachers, not the students.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW