Michael Radcliffe’s Sept. 20 letter, “Fear-mongering over fuel rods,” makes dangerous and unsupported claims about the nuclear situation at Fukushima. Apparently we are to believe that a nuclear disaster is no big deal and that we should all just take a breather.
Really? How does Radcliffe, who does not identify his expertise, know that nuclear expert Arnie Gundersen is any more unreliable in his assessment than Tokyo Electric Power Co.? Being pro-nuclear does not make one more objective than being anti-nuclear. As many inquiries have now proven, Tepco’s appalling safety record led to the disaster in the first place. In fact, Japan was lucky to scrape by with three nuclear meltdowns on March 11, 2011.
Radcliffe claims that it is “physically impossible” for the fuel rods to catch fire, but offers no scientific basis for this statement. If there is no danger, why are fuel rods covered with water in the first place? How does he know there will not be an earthquake large enough to dislodge the fuel rods? If they are safe just lying in a pile, why was it necessary to reinforce the building?

With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.