Since coming to Japan some years ago, the most surprising fact I learned about the education system was that it is impossible for elementary and middle school students to fail and repeat a grade.
Amid the debate over the value of adding Saturday classes, we could modify retired NASA astronaut Frank Borman’s statement about capitalism and bankruptcy to read: “School without failure is like Christianity without Hell.” In an environment where the results are the same for both the student who works hard and the student who sleeps in every class, is it surprising that Japanese schools have many of the latter and few of the former?
Rather than focusing on the number of hours spent warming a seat, schools should focus on the results. Of course, this would run counter to the prevailing reality that the primary purpose of compulsory education in Japan is to teach children how to be “Japanese” — not how to read, write and do arithmetic.

With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.