Regarding the Feb. 14 AFP article “Tibetan in Nepal 100th to set self on fire since ’09“: I am sure that anyone who grew up with 20th- century values should be appalled by this continuing campaign of suicide and self-torture. However, I use the word “should.” A great many people — Westerners in particular — seem unable to approach the Tibetan problem with any kind of balance. This would seem to be the result of a kind of fairy-tale thinking.

The worst aspect of this is the tendency to regard every self-immolation as if the perpetrator were entirely justified committing such a horrific act, and to blame this carnage on China. At the same time, the fanatical lamas who goad young people (including recently a 16-year-old girl) into committing these acts — in much the same way that Islamist groups goad the faithful into becoming suicide bombers — are seldom mentioned.

When Tibet was ruled by the lamas, it was a brutal theocracy with a rigid caste system that included “unseeables” as well as untouchables, a far cry from the Shangri-La nonsense of novels. It has also been under Chinese suzerainty for centuries, and very few Chinese — including on Taiwan — consider China’s invasion an act of aggression. I’m not saying their view is right, but the situation is more complex than under-informed Westerners imagine.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW