In his March 13 commentary, “What critics of North Korea summit get wrong,” Peter Van Buren adduces four errors on the part of those who criticize U.S. President Donald Trump’s proposed summit with North Korea’s Kim Jong Un. Sadly, each of his arguments is fatally flawed.
First, Van Buren says that critics claim that the proposed summit will legitimize North Korea, but that “Washington already recognizes North Korea as a nation state.” This is obvious but not the issue, which is that Washington has not recognized the North Korean regime. (Recognition is granted by establishing diplomatic relations.)
Second, Van Buren says it is disingenuous to claim that there is no one to negotiate with North Korea at the State Department because the ranks are “gutted.” He then names three current Korea experts at state. This might be a persuasive argument if Trump had any trust whatsoever in these officials. But since he is the one who engineered the gutting and routinely refers to government workers as part of a “swamp” and “deep state,” there is no realistic possibility he would elevate such “bureaucrats” to negotiating positions.

With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.