Last weekend marked 20 years since the attacks on the United States that launched the “Global War on Terror.” During that time, there have been not just two invasions, but also a global financial crisis, a pandemic and a foundational shift in relations among the world’s leading powers.
While former Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai, might encourage caution in drawing conclusions, two decades seem to be sufficient time to try to distill some lessons from this tumultuous chapter in world history.
First, the most powerful military in the world is the answer to some, but certainly not all, of the world’s problems. The Taliban were driven from power, al-Qaida vanquished and Osama bin Laden killed — but all those victories proved temporary. Many of those threats scattered and metastasized. Military capability is a critical element of national power and there are some problems for which it is the only answer, but we should also ask to what degree the use of the military helped our adversaries, alienating publics and amplifying a message that the U.S. was the real threat.
Second, the U.S. (and its allies and partners) must appreciate the limits of its power more broadly. Once again, a pipsqueak, Third World (terms meant to be incendiary) military managed to defeat not just the country with the greatest military, but one with the world’s largest economy, along with its allies and partners. The resources — financial, human, intellectual — of the world’s largest and richest countries were unable to prevail in the contest for the future of Afghanistan. They could not provide stability or the foundation for a self-sustaining government.
The third point follows from the first two: Strategy matters. War is still politics by other means. It is not an experiment in techniques and technologies; it is the pursuit of national objectives through a distinct means, and that relationship must remain foremost in the minds of politicians and planners.
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.