Blake Lemoine, a senior software engineer in Google’s Responsible AI organization, recently made claims that one of the company’s products was a sentient being with consciousness and a soul.

Field experts have not backed him up, and Google has placed him on paid leave. Lemoine’s claims are about the artificial-intelligence chatbot called laMDA. But I am most interested in the general question: If an AI were sentient in some relevant sense, how would we know? What standard should we apply? It is easy to mock Lemoine, but will our own future guesses be much better?

The most popular standard is what is known as the “Turing test”: If a human converses with an AI program but cannot tell it is an AI program, then it has passed the Turing test.

This is obviously a deficient benchmark. A machine might fool me by generating an optical illusion — movie projectors do this all the time — but that doesn’t mean the machine is sentient. Furthermore, as Michelle Dawson and I have argued, Turing himself did not apply this test. Rather, he was saying that some spectacularly inarticulate beings (and he was sometimes one of them) could be highly intelligent nonetheless.

Matters get stickier yet if we pose a simple question about whether humans are sentient. Of course we are, you might think to yourself as you read this column and consider the question. But much of our lives does not appear to be conducted on a sentient basis.

In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.

SUBSCRIBE NOW