With Marie Kondo and those tidy soccer fans representing Japan overseas, you’d be forgiven for thinking that everything is spick and span at home. This week, Alex K.T. Martin looks at what form compulsive hoarding disorder takes in Japan and how it manifests when combined with other aspects of life here.
Hosted by Shaun McKenna and produced by Dave Cortez.
On this episode:
Read more/Watch more:
- Deal with clutter while the choice to toss is still yours (Louise George Kittaka, The Japan Times)
- In graying Japan, pet hoarding proving to be a pesky problem (Kyodo)
- RiskBenefit
Get in touch: Send us feedback at deepdive@japantimes.co.jp. Support the show by rating, reviewing and sharing the episode with a friend if you’ve enjoyed it. And don’t forget to follow us on Twitter!
Transcript:
Note: Deep Dive is made to be listened to, and we recommend this transcript be used as an accompaniment to the episode. This transcript has been generated using a combination of speech recognition software and human transcription, and may contain errors. Please check its accuracy against the episode.
Shaun McKenna 00:05
Welcome to Deep Dive from The Japan Times. I’m Shaun McKenna. And Happy New Year to all our listeners, this is our first episode back from after the break. The reason that I might sound out of breath is because I’m currently walking very quickly through the backstreets of Tokyo to meet up with our writer, Alex K.T. Martin, before we head to the studio … oh, there’s Alex right there. Hey!
Alex Martin 00:28
Hey, Shaun! Happy New Year.
Shaun McKenna 00:30
Happy New Year. OK, Alex, where are we just now?
Alex Martin 00:33
Right. So right now we’re in Taito Ward, somewhat north of central Tokyo. This is near my neighborhood.
Shaun McKenna 00:40
OK, and why are we here?
Alex Martin 00:42
Yes, so, I’ve been working on a story about hoarding and hoarding behavior. And what we just walked past is a hoarder house.
Shaun McKenna 00:49
Right, gotcha. OK, we’re gonna keep walking, we don’t want to stare at the house. But it was a two-storey cement building, painted bright yellow … and there’s blue netting on the outside trying to contain various piles of … it looks like appliances?
Alex Martin 01:07
Yes, electrical appliances, that’s likely no longer being used. Some bicycles, old bicycles, and a lot of paper and paper bags and plastic bags. I see.
Shaun McKenna 01:19
Right, there’s a sign there. What does the sign say?
Alex Martin 01:21
It says, “This place isn’t a trash disposal site.”
Shaun McKenna 01:24
Right, OK, I guess they don’t want people adding to the pile.
Alex Martin 01:28
For sure, for sure.
Shaun McKenna 01:29
The neighbors can’t be too happy about this, this is a really thin street.
Alex Martin 01:33
Of course, yes. Actually, a couple of years ago, it was much worse, there was much more stuff sort of pouring out of the property. And then I think the officials came in at some point and put them all within the property. So, it’s actually much better now. But as you can see, it’s still quite messy now.
Shaun McKenna 01:50
Right, right. OK, let’s get back to the studio, and we’ll continue our conversation.
Alex Martin 01:54
Great, thank you.
Shaun McKenna 02:03
OK, we’re back in the studio. Alex, one of the big side stories of the World Cup was of these Japanese soccer fans who would clean up the stadium after the matches. And a lot of reporting would talk about how clean Japan is.
Media clip 02:16
The Japanese national team made headlines around the world this week after their sensational 2-1 victory against Germany. But their supporters got almost as much attention for their behavior in the stadium when they stayed behind to diligently clean up their litter and ensured that they left the place pretty much exactly as they found it.
Shaun McKenna 02:37
So I was pretty intrigued when I heard you were doing a story on hoarding.
Alex Martin 02:41
Thanks, Shaun. Yeah, well, as you know, Tokyo is quite a clean city, even compared to other major cities. However, that doesn’t mean that hoarding doesn’t exist here.
Shaun McKenna 02:50
What is the word for “hoarder” in Japanese?
Alex Martin 02:52
There’s no word for “hoarder,” but there are words for “hoarder houses” called gomi-yashiki — gomi is “trash” and yashiki is “house.” Or, obeya, the kanji for o is (the same as in) kitanai, which is “not clean,” heya is “room.” I think this word came because a lot of people live in apartments, they don’t actually live in homes or houses. So you either call them people living in gomi-yashiki or in an obeya.
Shaun McKenna 03:16
Overseas, hoarding is recognized as a mental disorder. Is it the same in Japan?
Alex Martin 03:21
Yes, I think the American Psychiatric Association in 2013 designated hoarding as a disorder and Japan followed suit. In Japanese, they call it tamekomi-shō. Tamekomi is “hoarding,” so it’s a pretty direct translation of the phenomenon. However, I’m not sure if the term itself is widely recognized. People just say, you know, this person lives in a gomi-yashiki, in a hoarder house, or, you know, she lives in an obeya. I don’t think people really get into the mental situation too much here yet.
Shaun McKenna 03:52
In your piece on hoarding, which will come out this weekend in The Japan Times, you mentioned the American TV show “Hoarders.”
“Hoarders” clip 04:00
Good morning, everybody. I’m Dorothy Breininger, I’m a professional organizing expert and I specialize in hoarding. We really do want to be clear about there is a crisis here. I mean, bottom line, we want to pull out everything from the house so we can examine whether the rats have gotten to it, whether the mice have gotten to it.
Shaun McKenna 04:20
So that show, which has been airing on A&E since 2009, has actually done quite a bit to explain the psyche of those with compulsive hoarding disorder to a broad audience. I used to watch it when I was back in Canada. So, I kind of know what an American hoarder looks like. What does a Japanese hoarder look like?
Alex Martin 04:36
Well, first of all, I think it’s important to note that neither country really produces more hoarding than the other. The percentage of Americans with compulsive hoarding disorder is said to be around 2.6%, though some studies have said it could be as high as 6% of the population. That’s the same in Japan, too. I think it’s generally considered that around 2% to 6% of the population could have this particular disorder. And the Environment Ministry is doing a nationwide survey, they sent out questionnaires to all of the 1,700-plus municipalities in Japan, trying to get a figure of how many hoarder houses there are in these regions to get a broader idea of what the situation is. The results should be, I think, published on their website by the end of March before the fiscal year ends. Also, people living in Japan, you might notice that it’s not too common to sort of invite people over to your home for parties or just casually, compared to America, for example. So that could be one potential reason behind the difficulty in assessing how many hoarder houses there are, or how many hoarders there are.
Shaun McKenna 05:40
OK, that was essentially the case of Hana Fujiwara, who you interviewed for your piece. She had a surprise visitor who had a pretty negative reaction to her living situation, right?
Alex Martin 05:50
That’s correct. So Hana told me that up until high school, her room was quite clean, she didn’t have that many possessions to begin with. But during college, she began living on her own, and immediately I think she began cluttering her home. And during university, she was dating this guy, but she never invited him over to her home because she knew that her place wasn’t too clean. But one day, he just called her up and told her that, you know, “Can I drop by?” And she couldn’t say no. So he came up, rang the doorbell, opened the door, and then took a look inside and didn’t say anything. He just went off and disappeared. And the next day, she received a text message saying that, you know, he wants to break up.
Shaun McKenna 06:27
Ouch. Yeah, that’s not good. Is that what pushed her to clean up her place, eventually?
Alex Martin 06:32
Actually, no, it took several years for her to sort of get her courage together to embark on this decluttering mission. The trigger was she lost her pension book, her nenkin techō, in her apartment. It may sound like a mundane event, but she actually calculated the number of minutes and hours she spent looking for these things, and realized that she’s losing so much time, precious time, out of her life. And that’s what really sort of triggered her to go on this cleaning campaign. And now she lives in an extremely clean apartment near Tokyo. She’s almost obsessive in keeping it clean. She told me that she doesn’t even leave her remote control devices on her table. She puts them back into drawers after she uses them. So she’s extremely conscious of keeping her place clean.
Shaun McKenna 07:16
So is Hana your typical Japanese hoarder?
Alex Martin 07:19
Well, obviously there are many types of hoarders in Japan, as is elsewhere, Hana may be part of one group of people who will shop compulsively as a form of stress release. She told me she owned 27 coffee mugs at one point. And this demographic, maybe, mostly comprised by women.
Shaun McKenna 07:46
What are some other types of hoarders in Japan?
Alex Martin 07:48
Well, people who maybe aren’t prone to hoarding, but fall into this category are those who work in high-stress jobs like doctors and hotel clerks. They’re never home. They’re working very hard, long hours. And they find that the clutter just piles up. And before they know it, it’s just overrunning their environment. I even learned about a group called “Amazon-yashiki.” This is a term a cleaning company designated to homes with piles of unopened Amazon delivery boxes.
Shaun McKenna 08:14
What, the company Amazon?
Alex Martin 08:15
Yes. Right. Referring to the E commerce giant, yes. It doesn’t necessarily have to be an Amazon box. But this is the term that you know, they used. And I think this became more of a phenomenon during the pandemic when people stayed home and the number of deliveries soared. But hoarding is also becoming quite common among the elderly, some may have compulsive hoarding disorder, or others may just be unable to clean their place up. I was told of a situation of a woman in her 70s or 80s, living in Shizuoka, she was living on the third floor of an apartment without an elevator. And what would happen with her is she was getting old, her mobility was deteriorating, so she couldn’t physically bring the garbage down to the garbage collection area. So what would happen is these bags of garbage would just keep on piling up in her home.
Shaun McKenna 09:03
She didn’t have any help?
Alex Martin 09:05
Well, in her particular situation, she would go to day care centers every day, and the people would come to pick her up. However, the staff workers at this day care center apparently told this special cleaner that I talked to that cleaning her place up and taking the trash out wasn’t part of the responsibilities. So I think similar cases are increasing in Japan, especially because there’s been a surge of one-person households in recent years. 1 in 5 of those were over the age of 65, they’re living on their own. So you have many, many older people living alone. And obviously, if you get too old or you reach a certain age and your functions start deteriorating, it’s going to become more harder for you to take the garbage out and do some heavy lifting, obviously. There’s also been a growing trend of unemployed children living with their parents till well into adulthood. This is not directly related to compulsive hoarding, but it’s sort of related. I spoke to a Dr. Nakao, who is a psychiatrist, for this piece and he is an expert on compulsive hoarding, and he called this the 80-50 problem.
Shaun McKenna 10:02
80-50?
Alex Martin 10:03
Yes, essentially 80something parents living with unemployed 50something children. And what happens is, you know, the parents, they try their best to do a lot for the kids, you know, cook meals, give them some allowances, obviously take out the garbage, but what happens when the parents pass away. You have these adults in their 50s, often they’re called hikikomori, the people who sort of recluses living in their homes. Right, and everything was taken care of by their parents, but they’ve lost their parents and their home could easily clutter up very fast.
Shaun McKenna 10:36
Is there anything else that might be specific to hoarding situations in Japan? Like things that may not exist in other countries?
Alex Martin 10:42
Yes, people living here might notice that each region, each ward each municipality, they have a pretty complicated system for disposing trash. Certain things don’t get collected until you really ask for it or, you know, sign up for it. And I’m sure you’ve dealt with this yourself, Shaun. Right.
Shaun McKenna 10:58
You know what, right now I have a broken TV sitting in my apartment, and I think I have to call the manufacturer and ask them how to dispose of it, I really don’t know.
Alex Martin 11:07
Right, so there’s a lot of bureaucracy and some hoarders just don’t know how to deal with it. And also, apartments here, in big cities, especially tend to be really small, which might lead to a hoarding situation more quickly, if you’re piling things up. And if the hoarding situation is happening in an apartment, then the other neighbors might be affected. Well, not necessarily just apartments, but houses as well, by an increase in odors of, you know, vermin and cockroaches and sort of food left out for some time.
Shaun McKenna 11:32
Are there any laws against hoarding, like when do the authorities have to step in?
Alex Martin 11:37
It’s very difficult because if the garbage is confined to one apartment, then authorities can only give a warning. You know, there are private property laws in place, you know, you can’t just go in, tell them to clean up. However, there have been ordinances set up in many wards in Tokyo, for example. And if the trash or garbage or the stuff that’s accumulated spills into other people’s properties, or if the smell is just way too intense, or if there’s just you know, too many cockroaches or other sort of vermin being produced or attracted to the garbage, they could technically go and ask them to clean up or even forcibly sort of try to contain the stuff inside their property. But the actual cases of something like this happening is extremely rare. I talked to an official in Setagaya Ward and he told me there’s only been one instance when they actually had to sort of forcibly clean a place up.
Shaun McKenna 12:26
So I guess the place that we went to earlier, that would have been why they had that blue mesh kind of net, keeping all the garbage away from the street.
Alex Martin 12:35
As I mentioned to you when we were walking past the place, it used to be 10 times worse several years back. And then at one point, I think people came in and pushed the stuff into the property so it doesn’t spill over to the road.
“Tidying Up with Marie Kondo” clip 13:01
Hello, I’m Marie Kondo. Let’s start tidying!
Shaun McKenna 13:10
So that was a clip from the Netflix show “Tidying Up with Marie Kondo.” Kondo has, along with the throngs of tidy soccer fans, given Japan quite the reputation for cleanliness. But when you can’t call Marie Kondo, you call Toru Koremura and RiskBenefit. What exactly does RiskBenefit do?
Alex Martin 13:29
So RiskBenefit is a so-called special cleaning company, in Japanese you call it a “tokushu seisō” — tokushu is “special,” seisō is “cleaning” — they get called into situations where the regular elbow grease won’t cut it, so homes with, you know, extreme amounts of clutter or garbage or trash, homes where the residents have died alone, perhaps, and often body fluids could contaminate the area. So you know regular cleaning won’t really cut it. So they would go in with special devices, masks and all those gears to solve the situation.
Shaun McKenna 13:59
Actually, I was looking into them and they were called to help with the cleaning of the Diamond Princess, that cruise ship that docked in Tokyo Bay, and was the focus of coronavirus fears at the start of the pandemic. So who calls RiskBenefit? Is it a relative or is it the authorities?
Alex Martin 14:15
Obviously case by case, but from what I hear oftentimes it’s relatives of the hoarder, getting concerned, and sort of convincing the hoarder themselves to accept a cleaning crew to come in. If not the hoarders themselves. I’ve heard about a young lady in their 20s or 30s, calling up Koremura’s company and asking them to come over to sort of give an estimate of how much it might cost to clean the place up. She ditched the appointment at the end. He says that often happens because people are generally ashamed of showing their cluttered home to other people and I think it takes a lot of courage for them to call them up. But I think those are the most common situations relatives are themselves.
Shaun McKenna 14:54
Right, actually a big part of the TV show hoarders involves aftercare with the people who have compulsive hoarding disorder. Does RiskBenefit take part in any kind of aftercare? Are there any kind of like…?
Alex Martin 15:07
Well, the job of the special cleaning companies, and there are numerous ones all over Japan, their job is to, you know, go in and clean the place up. That’s their primary goal. It’s not part of their job to conduct any psychological aftercare and things like that. That’s the job of a psychiatrist. And I think it’s that so as mentioned before, compulsive hoarding disorder was designated a disorder back in 2013, in the United States. So it’s a relatively new concept, I think that a lot of doctors and scientists are trying to tackle, it has connections or links to other disorders like Obsessive Compulsive Disorder or ADHD, or even depression. So if a psychiatrist can figure out, you know, what the underlying issue is, they could potentially prescribe medication or you know, offer counseling. Um, it really depends individual to individual.
Shaun McKenna 15:54
Right. So getting back to Hana Fujiwara, who you interviewed for the story, she didn’t use a service like RiskBenefit, right?
Alex Martin 16:03
Right. Well, her case was, I would call it a mild case of hoarding. I might have shown you some of the photographs that risk benefit provided for my story, where you know, homes are just filled to the ceiling with bags of trash and empty plastic bottles, plastic bottles seems to be a thing in Japan, a lot of homes, I would assume because people they need to be recycled and they would take the label off, get it ready to be recycled, but then they just don’t have enough energy to go down and take it to the trash disposal area, I’m just assuming. But anyway, going back to Hana Fujiwara, I’m sure her house was quite cluttered, from what I hear. She gave me some details of how it looked like before. She had the plastic sheet covered up all over the floor just because she knew that she was going to clutter the place up. She rarely did housecleaning, magazines, clothes, boxes, they’re all over the place. However, she decided after she lost her pension booklet that he was just going to do this on her own. And what she did was she said she tackled it like, like a job, like work. So she created an Excel sheet, and divvied everything up by week, it was like a three-months plan, like a three-month battle plan. So every week, she would have like a, like an aim, like, you know, a goal — how many bags of trash that she wants to get disposed of. And she would update that weekly, and then she had her friends and family come in to help her out. And I think she finished the job in like a little bit more than two months. At the end, she hired a truck, they have these special truck services, where you can just stuff as much junk, regardless of the category of the junk, into a truck for a fee. And then they take it to like a waste disposal site. So she used that and I think she filled up a truck with a lot of stuff. And that wasn’t even enough, but she got the job done eventually.
Shaun McKenna 17:47
She even kind of put this plan of attack on a blog or something for other hoarders.
Alex Martin 17:52
Yes, that’s correct. And she actually published a book about her own ordeal or her own adventure late last year. And what she does now is she often posts photographs of her current home, which is extremely clean, you know, white walls, it’s like a sort of a, it doesn’t even look like a person’s home because it’s so clean now. And she told me that you know, she does this to sort of keep your motivation high. She shows these photographs on her Twitter feed or on her blog. And she tells herself that, you know, I want to keep it this way. She doesn’t want to go back to what it was before.
Shaun McKenna 18:21
Well, I’m glad to hear she’s doing well. Alex, thanks for coming back to Deep Dive. Just make sure you tidy up before you leave.
Alex Martin 18:28
I’ll try my best, thanks.
Shaun McKenna 18:33
Thank you again to Alex for coming on Deep Dive. Elsewhere in the news, Prime Minister Fumio Kishida wrapped up a five-nation tour of G7 countries to set up the groundwork for a group summit being held in Hiroshima in May.
And this past Sunday marked three years since the first confirmed case of COVID-19 in Japan. The anniversary came as reports surfaced that the government is considering lifting its recommendations that people wear face masks indoors unless they are exhibiting symptoms of the virus. Anti-coronavirus measures were revised last May to encourage people to stop masking outdoors, however at present a vast majority of the population in the major cities continue to wear masks despite the change.
Production for Deep Dive is by Dave Cortez. Our intern is Natalia Makohon, and outgoing music is by Oscar Boyd. Our theme song is by LLLL. Until next time, podtsukaresama.
